Pizza Hut Announces The Return Of ‘The Big New Yorker’ Pizza Hut has announced the return ‘The Big New Yorker’ Pizza. The fan-favorite pizza was first introduced in 1999 and retired two decades ago. The pizza is a whopping 16 inches and “topped with extra cheese, sweet marinara sauce, parmesan-oregano topping, and double pepperoni.” L.O.V.E. ‘The Big New Yorker’ Pizza returns nationwide on February 1. What is your favorite pizza topping?